seere wrote:General Death...what is your absolute honest opinion regarding the game and the MDK?
I am aware through visiting various forums that you have tried extremely hard from a public relations point of view to promote this latest edition to the series and I have also seen many a poster voicing their dissapointment.
You have a respected voice as far as i'm concerned and I would be interested to hear your point of view on the game ,its future and where you think us modders can take it.
Many thx.
Seere.
Personally I think it?s a good game with a good set of tools for modification. With a couple more patches and Linux support I see it going much further. I have tried really hard to help EALA/TKO on this project simply because they have tried really hard to listen to the communities input into the game and input into the MDK.
There have been several times that I was about to hang it up on the project as it seemed like the communication was only flowing one way yet I have to remind myself that this is a first for the company on the moh series and hopefully a lot is and will be learned from the experience.
There are several things really holding back the game and mods atm. You have a game that requires "new" pc hardware to run and simply put there are a lot of kids that don?t have that cash and don?t understand why it will not perform at the level that AA did on there pc. No Linux support is killing server admins and server providers. This has been in the works for a long time now yet many on the MOHTeam said that this would be very important to the games MP survival months and months ago....EALA dropped the ball on this one. We were well aware that you can?t start the Linux binaries until the server code is complete but that should have been scheduled better imo. A buggy product has not helped matters at all. Everyone knows that you can?t get a software product "bug-free" yet I would have hoped that the bugs that made it into the final product were not as major as they were. Lastly, no one knows how to run the MDK and the docs that came with it are great but leave out key details. That?s not a huge problem as I will take care of that soon. I feel like I have been about the only one debugging it on the MODTeam...lol.
There are several things that make the game great and provide potential for the future. IMO the game has great gameplay and I for one am very tired of the European theater. It was great to have a ww2 fps game that finally spent some time in the pacific. This is something the Hell in the Pacific team that I was a project admin of worked on for years. We are a patch or two away from a solid game. Even though its buggy we are about to have more support in months after the game is released then in the years of the old moh series. EALA's support of the title fixing bugs will give it potential for long life. The mod tools in the MDK consist of all the tools needed other then Photoshop to create and mod you want up to a TC mod. I can see once I get some easy to follow tutorials out into he hands of the modders this game take off if the above items are fixed.
So I have tried hard simply because I think it?s a great game. It runs ok on my old machine, has a great set of mod tools debugged by modders, has great gameplay, and still feels like moh to me.
I don?t get paid by EALA and/or TKO nor would I care to have a job from them. I simply call it how I see it and to me this is why I still support the title.
I have seen the "disappointment" also on the net and I have to say from what I have seen it boils down to these main reasons:
*They can?t run the game on there old machine and don?t have the cash to upgrade. They want it to run on win98 with an 800 MHz CPU and a 32mb MX card.
*They simply don?t like EA due to moh's past.
*They think it?s to buggy and yet don?t care that it?s being patched.
*They think it should look and run like Farcry.....I don?t get that one.
*They don?t like the pacific theater.
The above reasons really don?t give you enough factual info to base a choice on if you should get the game our not. One can really only go off of the demo and EALA simply messed up bad on it. They game plays nothing like the demo yet what else can you go off of.
So to sum it all up it?s a good game with good potential and good mod tools that has had a rocky start once released to the public. Hopefully the second demo to be released soon will clear things up for those that still don?t know if they should get it or not.
I did not buy the game as EALA gave me a copy along with others that helped on the title yet I would buy it even in its current state.